Re-Imagining Arts Higher Education

With classes out of session, hopefully the middle of summer provides some time for those of us involved with arts higher education to reflect on our curriculum, requirements, and goals.

The educational model for the vast majority arts programs today is virtually identical (within each discipline) from university to university. Though each school certainly has unique strengths and weaknesses, most are designed around the same basic framework. In a world where all of the rules seem to be changing at a breakneck pace, is there not room for a few brave programs to adopt unconventional, innovative approaches? If some were bold enough to re-imagine parts of their structure, might there be benefits to both students and the institution?

Of course, just because something is common doesn’t inherently make it ineffective. Conversely, different doesn’t automatically mean superior. And solving one problem typically creates a host of others.

That said, it is hardly controversial to suggest that the arts world can benefit from new thinking and fresh solutions. Why not mirror that reality by offering an assortment of archetypes across arts higher education?

Imagine, for example, how the following reforms would impact the educational experience. Please understand, I am not necessarily recommending that programs adopt all of the changes below, or even any of them. The point here is that there are many ways to approach arts and education, and society benefits from a greater menu of perspectives.

Paradigm 1: AUDITIONS

  • Traditional model. Acceptance process is based on artistic ability, grades, and college entrance exams (like the SAT).
  • An alternative. Acceptance also weighs other issues such as creativity, leadership, collaborative skills, or entrepreneurial inclinations.

Paradigm 2: MAJORING IN THE ARTS

  • Traditional model. Students are expected to choose a major in a singular artistic field.  (Some programs allow “double majoring,” but this options typically requires more time in school.)
  • An alternative. Encourage or require students to select at least two areas of specialty throughout their single degree program. This priority reflects the real world, where artists must possess multiple skill sets to survive and thrive.

Paradigm 3: CURRICULUM

  • Traditional model. Most curricula are chock full of requirements, with very little room for electives.
  • An alternative. Create programs with a high percentage of electives (combined with outstanding advising), allowing students to create a unique education specifically relevant to them.

Paradigm 4: CLASSES & ASSIGNMENTS

  • Traditional model. Classes are typically built around a lecture. Students are assigned homework or projects to complete on their own time.
  • An alternative. On their own time, students watch lectures online. During class, the teacher works interactively with them on homework, projects, and other experiential endeavors.

Paradigm 5: PRIVATE LESSONS

  • Traditional model. Music students typically take a one hour lesson with a specialist in their area each week (i.e. violinist study with violin professors).
  • Alternative A. For at least one semester, each student studies with someone from another artistic specialty. Imagine the lessons a violinist might learn from a cellist, trombonist, dancer, or painter.
  • Alternative B. For at least one semester, each student studies with a career mentor rather than an artistic one (or does both).
  • Alternative C. Teachers are in their office for certain hours each week. Students are free to show up as often as they want, and stay as long as they desire. If unprepared one week, perhaps they shouldn’t waste the teacher’s time with a meeting. On the other hand, maybe someone could benefit from 3 lessons a week leading to an audition. This open structure also allows students to observe their teacher interacting with others who face similar/different challenges, teaching valuable lessons in pedagogy and beyond. (This is the model I experienced when studying composition at the Hochschule für Musik in Vienna, Austria).

Paradigm 6: ARTS HISTORY

  • Traditional model. History classes are taught chronologically, focusing on masterworks and masterminds.
  • Alternative A. Approach this class in reverse chronology, starting with what is relevant today. (Incidentally, this is how history really works. Everyone lives in the present, and is informed by what came before.)
  • Alternative B. Additional focus placed on the business models of artists throughout history, successful and not, since that is a challenge that will surely face our students.

Paradigm 7: THEORY CLASS

  • Traditional model. Most energy focused on developing technique. Secondary emphasis on learning literature. Smallest emphasis on creative projects (improv, composition, etc.).
  • An alternative. Flip the equation.

Paradigm 8: ARTS EDUCATION

  • Traditional model. Student teaching takes place during the last year of study, after students have “learned” many tricks of the trade.
  • An alternative. Student teaching also occurs during the first year of study. This shows them what needs to be learned early on, and frames their entire college experience.

Paradigm 9: DOCTORAL EXAMS

  • Traditional model. After coursework is complete, doctoral candidates take oral exams covering a huge body of information, some of which was learned during the degree. (I studied for eight months prior to my orals, 12 hours per day. Though I hate to brag, if you had met me the day of orals, I was really smart!  That day…)
  • An alternative. Begin the degree with some version of orals. Get people excited about researching and learning on their own before choosing classes.

Paradigm 10: DEGREE RECITALS

  • Traditional model. For musicians, this solo recitals features a pre-determined assortment of styles performed in a school hall very well.
  • Alternative A. See the article here.
  • Alternative B. Require chamber recitals instead of solo events, emphasizing the importance of collaboration.

Paradigm 11: INTERNSHIPS

  • Traditional model. Students in some majors are required to complete a summer or semester-long internship as part of their degree program.
  • An alternative. Partner students with an external organization throughout their studies, so they are constantly challenged by real-world, practical concerns and trends.

Paradigm 12: FACULTY SCHOLARSHIP

  • Traditional model. Tenure-track/tenured faculty members are required to publish or produce other scholarship in an area of expertise. Institutions tend to value: 1) peer-reviewed, 2) national/international profile, 3) non-teaching, and non-service related (writing a textbook or helping out a local community are nice, but they usually counts as “teaching” or “service” respectively, not “scholarship”).
  • Alternative A. Give the option of weighing scholarship by other metrics. If your provocative blog post is read by 100,000 people, its impact may be as great or greater than an article written for an academic journal read only by a handful of like-minded specialists.
  • Alternative B. Reward people for making a difference locally, rather than placing highest value on out of town initiatives.
  • Alternative C. Emphasize the importance of research related to teaching and doing meaningful work within the community by carving a path for some of these activities to count as “scholarship.”

What do you think?  Let’s start a dialogue.

RELATED ARTICLES:


Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • Print
  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • Mixx
  • Blogplay
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz

270 Responses to “Re-Imagining Arts Higher Education”

  1. I do believe all of the ideas you have presented to your post. They are really convincing and will certainly work. Still, the posts are very brief for novices. Could you please prolong them a little from next time? Thank you for the post.

  2. I enjoyed your blog. great read.

  3. material, as a result of it might ceaselessly be pleasing to decide a warm and pleasant face or maybe hear a voice when initial landing.

  4. Performing this test repeatedly and often will assist you in establishing what the usual values are.I am feeling the RZ vibe with the leopard coat,Fagner Jersey, large shades, black skinny jeans, and Louboutin shoes. Furthermore, honesty is essential in producing a loyal reader base that will continue to generate money in the future.Nursing faculties themselves offer financial help to scholars. Doing this creates an emotional appeal, which will lead to more sales conversions. Once you have absor

  5. Jesse Grillo says:

    After looking over a number of the post posts on your blog, I seriously like your way of blogging. Interesting content.

  6. There are remarkable changes on the layout of the blog, I definitely enjoy that. My own is dealing with facetime android app and there are lots of stuff to do, I am currently a novice in web design. Take care!

  7. I was discussing with a buddy of my own about this info and also about coffee and espresso makers too. I do believe you made a few good points here, we’re also looking forward to keep reading material from you.

  8. See to it that the reviews made by the people are legit and would not cause issues to you. The internet and the World Wide Web have made finding the most remote of thing possible. One can also learn of the best companies in town,Vince Carter Womens Jersey, which provide these water accessories and even deliver of clean and hygienic drinking water.This is important because most cabins will access their water supply through their own private wells drilled into the ground. The speakers will be all

  9. Will there be a site that makes it easy to follow websites and pod-casts? I have no an ipod device, does that matter?.

  10. Collin says:

    Yes! Finally something about finals.

  11. Firman says:

    There are remarkable changes on the layout of the blog, I definitely enjoy that. My own is dealing with facetime android app and there are lots of stuff to do, I am currently a novice in web design. Take care!

  12. 美月先生の英語発音練習:https://www.mitsukienglish.jp/の授業はアメリカ英語の発音に特化したレッスンのアメリカ英語:https://www.mitsukienglish.jp/course/list?course_group_id=3サイトです。
    英語勉強レッスンはオンラインビデオの形式でご提供します。英語発音練習:https://www.mitsukienglish.jp/、
    英語発音練習、英語の発音のことなら、当店に任せ。すでに一定の英語能力をお持ちの方に英語発音練習:https://www.mitsukienglish.jp/course/list?course_group_id=1お勧めします。
    学生、会社員、公務員の方、また就職や転職、昇進試験の準備をしておられる方はもちろんのこと、ワンランク上の英語を身に着けたい方は是非https://www.mitsukienglish.jp/お試しください。

  13. click here says:

    You are certainly right and I understand you. Whenever you want, we could as well speak regarding smartphone reviews, something which fascinates me. Your website is truly brilliant, best wishes!

  14. I was discussing with a buddy of mine around this article and also regarding important apps for android too. I think you made a few good points in this case, we’re also excited to find out more information from you.

  15. I constantly read your content attentively. I am furthermore focused on new smartphones, perhaps you might discuss this from time to time. Good day.

  16. I was discussing with a friend of mine around this and even regarding smartphones for sale too. I do think you made a few very good points in this article, we’re also looking forward to continue reading information from you.

  17. I always read your site content carefully. I’m likewise considering smartphones for sale, you could talk about this at times. Bye.

  18. There are certainly terrific changes on the style of this site, I really enjoy it. My site is on the subject of smartphone test and now there are lots of things to be done, I’m yet still a newcomer in website development. Take care!

  19. You are definitely right, I would like to know new information on that subject! I’m as well interested in free apps for android as I consider it truly is very unique now. Keep up the good work!

  20. My family and I definitely enjoy your site and find many of the blogposts to be what precisely I’m looking for. Would you offer people to write material for you? I would not mind writing an article relating to Arvind Pandit or maybe on most of the topics you’re writing about on this page. Awesome website!

Leave a Reply

Powered by Wordpress | Designed by I Design Blogs