Classical Music: Too Elitist or Not Enough?

I spend a good deal of time dreaming up bold and unconventional success solutions for the arts. While these proposals typically receive serious consideration from some corners, there are others who emotionally shoot them down immediately without any rational thought whatsoever. It seems the closer someone is to a position, the more threatening a fresh alternative can feel. Even if the current model is clearly not working.

All too aware of this human tendency, I pride myself on considering the merits of any and every proposal. Even if my gut reaction is “NO!” Especially when that’s the case.

And so it was last week, while witnessing a keynote presentation by Brittish novelist and music critic Norman Lebrecht at the Dutch Classical Music Meeting. Author of Who Killed Classical Music? Lebrecht is renowned for thoughtful but provocative, controversial perspectives.

In a talk entitled Reframing the Classical Music Experience, Lebrecht declared that one word that has been taboo for decades in the classical music world. We shy away from it at all costs. But as organizations look for new solutions that enable vibrancy and sustainability, we no longer need to fear this concept. In fact, we should embrace it:

E – L – I – T – I – S – M

Why shouldn’t we be elitist, he asked? Classical musicians represent some of the finest talent on Earth. They spend a lifetime working tirelessly to perfect their craft. We should celebrate that phenomenon, making classical events a special, elite experience.

I cringed. Designing more accessible classical music experiences was core to the “Artistry and Relevance” chapter in my book The Savvy Musician. My message is one of adamant anti-elitism. Or better yet, resolute pro-people-ism.

Is Lebrecht completely wacky, I wondered? Or was my violent resistance simply caused by a closed mind, too attached to personal viewpoints to imagine new possibility? Could becoming more elitist actually help classical music?

Forcing myself to stay open and logical, I pondered whether a valuable lesson could be gleaned from his shocking contention. And after a week of working through this puzzle, here is my epiphany-in-progress.

Elite Access

Without a doubt, there are times where feeling elite motivates. For example, I fly a lot, and cherish my status. Elite Access. That’s what the airline calls it. Going in a special line, getting bumped to first class, raking in miles faster than the other guys. It just feels special, and encourages loyalty. As bizarre as it may sound to a non-frequent flyer, elite status helps define a part of my identity. “I am an elite world traveler.” Spectacular!

Lebrecht suggests that the classical music experience become more selective. More tuxedo…More long pieces…More expensive tickets…More sophisticated audiences…Would adopting that paradigm help build loyalty and, in turn, revenue?  

Hmmm…

Maybe the problem is that classical musicians today are too much in the middle.

“Anti-elitist” proponents make their concerts more friendly by featuring unusual venues, introducing pieces verbally, permitting the audience to clap between movements, and substituting business casual for wedding formal. But from an event perspective, these shows still pale in comparison to their popular music counterparts. The audiences still listen politely. Performers still hide behind music stands, sit respectfully center stage, and disappear during intermission. There are no light shows, mosh pits, dance competitions, Lady Gaga outfits, or sing-alongs. Such experiences may be profound, but not particularly populist.

On the other hand, consider more “serious” events such as traditional orchestra concerts. The hall is still breathtaking. The pieces are still long and glorious. The musicians still look as serious as brain surgeons. But these otherwise high society events are made slightly more accessible by the availability of cheaper tickets, pre-concert lectures (lectures?), and a conductor who shares some words from the stage. Slightly more approachable for the uninitiated, but also less exclusive.

Splitting the Difference

One gargantuan challenge for most classical organizations is expanding their fan base. The current audience consists primarily of seniors accustomed to time-tested conventions. But they hope to attract younger folks as well, who have different expectations about what a concert experience should deliver. So, in an attempt to be all things to all people, ensembles design some type of middleground that isn’t particularly elitist or populist. Said another way: In an age where many people seek extreme, niche experiences, these groups split the difference.

Two Classical Musics

Maybe we need two classical musics. Classical-A is exclusive, hardly available to the masses. For Elite Access, you must pony up, dress up, and pay up. Anyone who learns this club’s secret handshake is far above average. They are exceptional human beings with exceptional taste.

Classical-B provides hip, fun, interactive entertainment presented in user-friendly formats. The only audience these events discriminate against are ultra-snobby stuffed shirts, who eat caviar while wearing a monocle on their yacht. Of course, Classical-B still features extraordinary virtuosity, beauty, and many other unique dimensions its creators can access. But this is first and foremost an art of the people.

Cages & Rainbows

Norman Lebrecht may have rattled my cage, suggesting that expanded elitism might be good for classical music. It’s doubtful I’ll be joining that camp anytime soon. I’m too busy fighting for new audiences. For the opportunity to touch many more lives, not fewer.

But perhaps there’s a pot of gold on both ends of this rainbow.  The trick is committing to one side.

What do you think?

rainbow

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • Print
  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • Mixx
  • Blogplay
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz

66 Responses to “Classical Music: Too Elitist or Not Enough?”

  1. Earle Res says:

    I think this is one of the most important information for me. And i’m glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The website style is perfect, the articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers

  2. Te asteptam in cazul in care esti interesat de aceste servicii si doresti sa colaboram pentru succesul afacerii tale. Vom tine mereu cont de ideile si dorintele pe care le ai, si vom crea un site specific afacerii tale. Daca aveti un site web si acesta nu se bucura de succesul pe care il doriti, puteti apela la serviciile noastre pentru o promovare continut web, ceea ce va duce la cresterea semnificativa anumarului de vizitatori si a numarului de client interesati de serviciile si de produsele ce le oferiti spre vanzare.

  3. Kathleen says:

    I think one of the main reasons that “elitism” gets thrown around when we talk about art music is that the “uninitiated” don’t know how to talk about it. Ditto with other supposedly acquired tastes (e.g., wine tasting, ethnic gastronomy, even graphic arts). People become so afraid of being labeled as an uninitiated “noob” that they deny themselves their genuine interest in art music.

    Having read some of Lebrecht’s work, I have to say that he comes off as a passionate lover of music who likes his reputation for being such. Of course someone who writes books about art music and is considered a scholar is going to say that elitism should be encouraged. That would maintain a status quo that makes him elite in addition to elevating his chosen art form.

    I suppose I am a populist in the sense that I think everyone can appreciate and enjoy classical music, and that I believe that taste should be a listener’s determining factor instead of status or access.

  4. Together with every little thing that seems to be building within this specific subject material, many of your viewpoints are generally somewhat stimulating. On the other hand, I appologize, but I do not give credence to your whole suggestion, all be it stimulating none the less. It looks to everyone that your comments are actually not completely rationalized and in actuality you are yourself not completely confident of your assertion. In any event I did enjoy looking at it.

  5. Wow! This could be one specific of the most useful blogs We have ever arrive across on this subject. Really Superb. I’m also an professional in this subject therefore I can understand your hard function.

  6. スワンズ says:

    スワンズ…

    Perform the following to discover more on watch well before you are left out….

  7. qkctrwendj says:

    Classical Music: Too Elitist or Not Enough? | the savvy musican blog | The Savvy Musician Blog
    aqkctrwendj
    [url=http://www.g5482c80wivipv56vd07iin78r6ys310s.org/]uqkctrwendj[/url]
    qkctrwendj http://www.g5482c80wivipv56vd07iin78r6ys310s.org/

  8. Classical Music: Too Elitist or Not Enough? | the savvy musican blog | The Savvy Musician Blog
    Louis Vuitton Epi Bag Price
    Gucci 財布 メンズ 長 財布 グッチ バッグ セカンドバッグ
    louis vuitton artsy mm handbags
    2014 bottes en ligne
    エアジョーダン 口コミ エアジョーダン 靴ひも
    louis vuitton insolite wallet
    NIKE JERSEY MODELS
    ムートンブーツ 値段 Ugg 財布 メンズ
    2014 basket femme louboutin
    Ugg ローランド アグ 格安
    avis chaussure louboutin pas cher boutique
    louis vuitton bag shop online
    CAMISETA DE DORTMUND 15 HUMMELS 2013 SEGUNDA
    CAMISETA DE CHELSEA 17 HAZARD 2013 TERCERA
    camiseta de chelsea 2 ivanovic 2013 segunda
    Ballerines Noires Nouveau
    where can i find cheap nice saints jerseys
    Camiseta De Chelsea 4 David Luiz 2014 Primera
    2014 louboutin bordeaux
    Nike Air Force 1 Mid ナイキ エアマックス 価格
    louis vuitton artsy
    CHEAP CHINA WHOLESALE JERSEYS
    BALLERINES REPETTO POPULAIRES
    Camiseta De Chelsea 8 Lampard 2014 Primera
    Gucci 財布 オレンジ Gucci ローファー スエード
    cheap louis vuitton
    louis vuitton damier duomo handbag
    ナイキ フリー レディース ナイキ シューズ 種類
    ジョーダンシリーズ 一覧 ナイキ スニーカー ウェッジ
    http://starwarsbf2.altervista.org/star-wars-battlefront-2-4-2/aa26.jpg.html
    ugg アグ フラットシューズ アグ オーストラリア シューズ
    CHEAP AUTHENTIC NFL JERSEYS NIKE
    louis vuitton handbags outlet store
    ugg アメリカサイト ugg ミネトンカ 違い
    louis vuitton bag for women
    Gucci ノートカバー Gucci ヒステリア バッグ
    p gucci 財布 コピー 代引き き gucci ショルダー シマ
    ナイキ フリー ウォーク ナイキ スニーカー ターコイズ
    2014 chaussure fille pas cher
    LOUIS VUITTON HANDBAGS ONLINE
    グッチ 在庫 GUCCI 新作 リュック
    avis site christian chaussures louboutin Populaires
    nfl jerseys cheap china free shipping
    Ugg 色 人気 アグ 取扱店 名古屋
    Babies Chaussures Boutiques Spécialisées
    2014 chaussures talons hauts

  9. “Regional tourism department yesterday, Paris, France, an official said in an interview in June, Paris police cooperation with local tourism bureau published the Chinese version of the “Paris tourism safety guide, for Chinese tourists to provide tools for tackling the assault and robbery
    http://www.kelsport.net/newuk.asp

  10. Jinzhou after the park opened, immediately triggered penang tourist boom

  11. Salesoccershoe.com is the top destination to buy Football Shoes at great prices. We stock all the latest football boots from Nike and Adidas.With all top brand football boots and leading collections including Nike shoes and Adidas Shoes.

  12. “I used to be able to find good information from your articles.”

  13. Throughout this great pattern of things you actually secure an A just for hard work. Where you misplaced me was first on the facts. You know, they say, details make or break the argument.. And that couldn’t be much more true here. Having said that, permit me tell you precisely what did do the job. The authoring is actually really persuasive which is most likely the reason why I am taking the effort in order to opine. I do not make it a regular habit of doing that. Next, whilst I can notice the jumps in reasoning you come up with, I am not necessarily certain of just how you appear to connect your details which in turn produce your final result. For right now I will, no doubt yield to your position however trust in the near future you connect your facts much better.

Leave a Reply

Powered by Wordpress | Designed by I Design Blogs