Classical Music: Too Elitist or Not Enough?

I spend a good deal of time dreaming up bold and unconventional success solutions for the arts. While these proposals typically receive serious consideration from some corners, there are others who emotionally shoot them down immediately without any rational thought whatsoever. It seems the closer someone is to a position, the more threatening a fresh alternative can feel. Even if the current model is clearly not working.

All too aware of this human tendency, I pride myself on considering the merits of any and every proposal. Even if my gut reaction is “NO!” Especially when that’s the case.

And so it was last week, while witnessing a keynote presentation by Brittish novelist and music critic Norman Lebrecht at the Dutch Classical Music Meeting. Author of Who Killed Classical Music? Lebrecht is renowned for thoughtful but provocative, controversial perspectives.

In a talk entitled Reframing the Classical Music Experience, Lebrecht declared that one word that has been taboo for decades in the classical music world. We shy away from it at all costs. But as organizations look for new solutions that enable vibrancy and sustainability, we no longer need to fear this concept. In fact, we should embrace it:

E – L – I – T – I – S – M

Why shouldn’t we be elitist, he asked? Classical musicians represent some of the finest talent on Earth. They spend a lifetime working tirelessly to perfect their craft. We should celebrate that phenomenon, making classical events a special, elite experience.

I cringed. Designing more accessible classical music experiences was core to the “Artistry and Relevance” chapter in my book The Savvy Musician. My message is one of adamant anti-elitism. Or better yet, resolute pro-people-ism.

Is Lebrecht completely wacky, I wondered? Or was my violent resistance simply caused by a closed mind, too attached to personal viewpoints to imagine new possibility? Could becoming more elitist actually help classical music?

Forcing myself to stay open and logical, I pondered whether a valuable lesson could be gleaned from his shocking contention. And after a week of working through this puzzle, here is my epiphany-in-progress.

Elite Access

Without a doubt, there are times where feeling elite motivates. For example, I fly a lot, and cherish my status. Elite Access. That’s what the airline calls it. Going in a special line, getting bumped to first class, raking in miles faster than the other guys. It just feels special, and encourages loyalty. As bizarre as it may sound to a non-frequent flyer, elite status helps define a part of my identity. “I am an elite world traveler.” Spectacular!

Lebrecht suggests that the classical music experience become more selective. More tuxedo…More long pieces…More expensive tickets…More sophisticated audiences…Would adopting that paradigm help build loyalty and, in turn, revenue?  


Maybe the problem is that classical musicians today are too much in the middle.

“Anti-elitist” proponents make their concerts more friendly by featuring unusual venues, introducing pieces verbally, permitting the audience to clap between movements, and substituting business casual for wedding formal. But from an event perspective, these shows still pale in comparison to their popular music counterparts. The audiences still listen politely. Performers still hide behind music stands, sit respectfully center stage, and disappear during intermission. There are no light shows, mosh pits, dance competitions, Lady Gaga outfits, or sing-alongs. Such experiences may be profound, but not particularly populist.

On the other hand, consider more “serious” events such as traditional orchestra concerts. The hall is still breathtaking. The pieces are still long and glorious. The musicians still look as serious as brain surgeons. But these otherwise high society events are made slightly more accessible by the availability of cheaper tickets, pre-concert lectures (lectures?), and a conductor who shares some words from the stage. Slightly more approachable for the uninitiated, but also less exclusive.

Splitting the Difference

One gargantuan challenge for most classical organizations is expanding their fan base. The current audience consists primarily of seniors accustomed to time-tested conventions. But they hope to attract younger folks as well, who have different expectations about what a concert experience should deliver. So, in an attempt to be all things to all people, ensembles design some type of middleground that isn’t particularly elitist or populist. Said another way: In an age where many people seek extreme, niche experiences, these groups split the difference.

Two Classical Musics

Maybe we need two classical musics. Classical-A is exclusive, hardly available to the masses. For Elite Access, you must pony up, dress up, and pay up. Anyone who learns this club’s secret handshake is far above average. They are exceptional human beings with exceptional taste.

Classical-B provides hip, fun, interactive entertainment presented in user-friendly formats. The only audience these events discriminate against are ultra-snobby stuffed shirts, who eat caviar while wearing a monocle on their yacht. Of course, Classical-B still features extraordinary virtuosity, beauty, and many other unique dimensions its creators can access. But this is first and foremost an art of the people.

Cages & Rainbows

Norman Lebrecht may have rattled my cage, suggesting that expanded elitism might be good for classical music. It’s doubtful I’ll be joining that camp anytime soon. I’m too busy fighting for new audiences. For the opportunity to touch many more lives, not fewer.

But perhaps there’s a pot of gold on both ends of this rainbow.  The trick is committing to one side.

What do you think?


Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • Print
  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • Mixx
  • Blogplay
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz

175 Responses to “Classical Music: Too Elitist or Not Enough?”

  1. 绉併伅銈儠銉堛償銉冦偗鍫村悎銇€併亾銈屻倰鐭ャ仯銇︺亜銈嬨亴銆佺銇嚜鍒嗐伄濮嬨倎銇帰銇椼仸銇勩伨銇欍儢銉偘銇ㄥソ濂囧績銇椼仧銇欍伖銇︺亴蹇呰銇彇寰椼仚銈嬨伀銇紵绉併伅銇傘仾銇熴伄銈堛亞銇儢銉偘銇亱銇倞銇不鐢ㄣ亴銇嬨亱銈嬨仩銈嶃亞鎸併仱銇ㄤ划瀹氥仐銇︺亜銈嬶紵绉併伅浠娿仹銇仾銇勩€侀潪甯搞伀銈︺偋銉栫簿閫氥伄銇с€佺銇?00锛呫仹銇仾銇勩倱銇犳銆傘仼銈屻儝銉炽儓銈勩偄銉夈儛銈ゃ偣銈掋亜銇熴仩銇戙倢銇板垢銇勩仹銇欍€?鏍勫厜銇?
    pre orderjordan 11 72-10

  2. snap backs says:

    Highly energetic post 銇┿亾銇嬨倝銉勩儍銈炽倎銇般亜銇勩伄銇?(銇ゃ倢銇ャ倢鏃ヨ锛犳湀鍏夋ソ鍦? , I loved that a lot. Will there be a part 2?
    snap backs http://www.snap–

  3. Mungkin dia fikir aku melawak padahal aku serius sebenarnya. dia sudah berdiri di luar. Sayang tahu jelah pengalaman yang dibuat orang. Rin nak kahwin dengan dia tak?鈥渓epaskan saya!lalu aku memperbuatkan bubur untuknya. auntie. But we are talking about marrying someone for the rest of your life. Brek.鈥?Ainul jelir lidah.mak nak makan ke melantak?. 6 tahun yang baru masuk ke sekolah tadika. Celik sahaja, kesabaran dan hidayah yang berkekalan dalam menghadapi permainan dunia ini.鈥?Aunty Lily menyerahkan aku sepinggan nasi. Dok bawah ketiak mak la kerjanya. Oleh itu janganlah adinda bersedih lagi,lalu beredar turun ke arah Prince Zack.Dunia dah berputar 360 darjah ke?鈥滱pai menuturkan.
    new balance 574 ca

  4. I feel the loss intensely because such things shouldnt happen but did. i dont know what to say, but i wish your friend will find courage in the memories and try very hard against the impossible to find that happiness he so deserves and shouldnt have lost. i really dont know what to say 鈥ut 鈥 know how you feel.
    jimmy choo shoes uk http://www.jimmy–

  5. I want the prize like everybody else!

  6. beats by dr says:

    qu鈥檈n pensez-vous ? 810). viva il Web, accessoires funky, Cover MediaSa gueule dange et son jeu dacteur int茅ressent les plus grands r茅alisateurs.Ci?che la firma () pu?dire ?il notevole senso estetico che questo personaggio eccezionale portava dentro di s?a compensazione di frustrazioni subite. ex ministro Fli delle Politiche ComunitarieAlfano. tutti compresi, Et si vous pensez que ce nest pas votre 茅poque, Lissner ?approdato nel 2005.
    beats by dr http://beats-by–

  7. jordan 29 says:

    The Risks Of Fast Weight reduction
    jordan 29

  8. ghd says:

    When discovering this like those Nike Tshirts and also quirky fashion many publish. Are usually jordan kors wall socket bags sales a genuine safeguard with the procedure concerning guardianship trial what is more anticipate to emphasize that individual ex girl and guy posesses crucial enjoying crave? In case that consequently truth be told there safeguard procedures on the topic of someone in terms of purchase that may facts along with get ready taking that approach directly below location beneath guidance within your guardianship circumstances.
    ghd http://www.ghd–

  9. 銉偆銉淬偅銉堛兂 銉┿兂 Appreciation to my father who shared with me concerning this website, this website is genuinely remarkable.
    retro 11 bred

  10. Cheap Shoes says:

    Look great, look and feel fabulous and additionally my favorite little girl adores Cheap Shoes–!

  11. The fundamental principles behind watch that it’s possible to advantage from getting started today.
    jordan 7 french blue

  12. Pak we kau ker tue鈥? Tapi, Dia hidup di dunia ini pun atas belas ihsan daripada Allah. namun kehilangan mamanya masih tetap terasa. Razlan mengerut dahinya yang luas. Aku akan tarik diri jika kita ditakdirkan menyintai wanita yang sama. macam mana hubungan kau dengan Dhia? Dia tahu bahawa Kak Mila tidak ingin Aiza merasakan nasib sepertinya yang disisih oleh papa kerana berkahwin dengan abang kandungnya. Tiba-tiba.鈥淥ii. doctor bertugas sepenuh usaha menyelamatkan anakku.setelah berapa ketika
    womens tube socks http://tube–

  13. 鈥?Maya Ellisa memulakan bicaranya.Maya Ellisa tersenyum seraya menghela nafas lega.鈥?soal Dina Mariani yang pelik dengan sikap Diana Syuhada pada pagi itu.Maziah untuk menutup peristiwa yang terjadi tadi dari pengetahuan cucunya. Aku harap jugalah yang kotak ni sekadar kotak saja, Dia ni kan鈥ebelakangan ni,鈥滱ku menghela nafas panjang. Kelihatan gadis itu benar-benar menikmati kedamaian bayu.Fadhli sekadar mengagguk. Kenapa?
    football socks sale

  14. fake ugg says:

    效褌芯 褌芯 屑薪械 泻邪卸械褌褋褟 褔褌芯 屑邪谢芯 褝褌芯 屑械褋褌芯 斜褍写械褌 锌芯褏芯卸械 薪邪 褌芯 褔褌芯 褏芯褉芯褕芯 芯锌懈褋褘胁邪械褌褋褟 胁 泻薪懈卸泻邪褏(.
    fake ugg

  15. I should say, as a lot as I enjoyed reading what you had to say, I couldnt help but lose interest following a even though. Its as should you had a great grasp on the subject matter, but you forgot to contain your readers. Possibly you need to consider this from far far more than 1 angle. Or maybe you shouldnt generalise so considerably. Its better in case you take into consideration what others might have to say rather of just going for a gut reaction to the subject. Consider adjusting your own believed procedure and giving other people who may read this the benefit of the doubt.
    jordan 11lab4 2015

  16. 鈥淪he seems not have much to do that she encircles scheduling meetings unexpectedly as being a result teacher putting together an unplanned test just of your students miserable.鈥?That鈥檚 the spot where situation Karen has with your girlfriend boss few of the time and is also seriously due towards the fact quitting.Companies, cheaper signals possibly be more luckily attained than these the cost that you simply month鈥檚 earnings.Hardly ever have a serving is now single cabinet, with lots of ceremony.And has the benefit of stating I must return to correctly When i bought whereas therefore produced.
    new balance shoes

  17. 鎰夸綘浠殑瀹跺涵锛屾垚涓烘暀浼氬鍏寸殑涓€澶у姏閲忥紱涔熸垚涓虹ぞ浼氥€佸浗瀹剁殑涓€澶ц础鐚紒涓冨鎯呬汉鑺傚揩涔愶紒锛?
    retro 11 jordan

  18. 銇濄倢銇仩鍫村悎銇珅鐨?銇晱椤屻倰绉併伅鐭ャ倝銇亜銇屻倧銇嬨倝銇亜銇傘仾銇熴伄銈︺偋銉栥偟銈ゃ儓銆?銇竴閮ㄦ浉銇嬨倢銇熴儐銈偣銉堛伄銇傘仾銇熴偝銉炽儐銉炽儎銇屻偑銉曘伀瀹熻銇曘倢銇︺亜銈嬬敾闈€?浠栦汉銇撱仺銇屻仹銇嶃伨銇欍仐銇︺亸銇犮仌銇勩儠銈c兗銉夈儛銉冦偗銈掓彁渚涖€併亾銈屻伅褰笺倝銇綍銇岃捣銇撱仯銇︺亜銈嬨仾銈夈€佺銇煡銈夈仜銇︺亗銇俱倞銇紵绉併伅銇撱倢銇岃捣銇撱倠鎸併仯銇︺亜銇熴伄銇с€併偆銉炽偪銉笺儘銉冦儓銉栥儵銈︺偠 銇撱倢銇彲鑳芥€с亴銇傘倞銇俱仚鍓嶃伀浠ュ墠銆佺銇ㄥ晱椤屽晱椤屻仹銇傘倠銇撱仺銆?銇娿亱銇掋仹
    herve leger uk

  19. What is the best spot to establish a blog on?
    jordan 8 aqua 2015

  20. Cette Coupe avec les AC72 篓|tait une tentative trop extr篓ome, il faut l’admettre et revoir les r篓篓glements.
    jordan 8 aqua 2015

  21. Some genuinely nice and useful info on this website, also I think the style and design holds superb features.
    new balance 574 shoes

  22. An fascinating dialogue is value comment. I think that you must write extra on this matter, it may not be a taboo topic but generally individuals are not enough to speak on such topics. To the next. Cheers
    retro 11 legend blue

  23. Personally, fashion accessories accomplish a great clothing as they are among the most straightforward tips on how to enhance my best start looking. Allow us to visit a number of the device styles from new season 2011 the fact that women will easily fit into together with display.
    air force ones

  24. There are some interesting deadlines on this article however I don鈥檛 know if I see all of them center to heart. There is some validity however I’ll take maintain opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want more! Added to FeedBurner as nicely
    jordan 5 metallic silver 2015

  25. Siapa punya kerja ni? Terkaku aku seketika.Pergi sekolah hari ni.
    georgetown 11s 2015

Leave a Reply

Powered by Wordpress | Designed by I Design Blogs