Re-imagining the University Ensemble Experience

My article Re-imagining the Music Degree Recital explored ways that solo performances can serve as vehicles for developing critical career and problem solving skills.  But there are many other avenues with the potential to emphasize these aptitudes within music school curriculum. Consider, for example, the ensemble experience.

In Fall 2009, I began directing The Accidental Collective, Duquesne University’s premier contemporary music ensemble.  In addition to producing high quality concerts of compositions written in the last 10 years, I wanted the group to teach participants valuable skills about becoming a successful professional.  Please note: this is just one of many entrepreneurial methods for approaching an ensemble.  I do not recommend this format for every group or experience level. But it illustrates some of the potential available.


Success as a musician requires more than playing well. I wanted to stress that reality through even the audition process.  In addition to a traditional audition component, candidates were interviewed. This practice stressed that who you are is as important as how you play. Additionally, they filled out a form describing background, skills, and interests: secondary instruments, improvisation, composing/arranging, singing, public speaking, movement, additional competencies, reliability, willingness to take chances, etc. We also checked references.


Identifying the right members was also more important than the instruments they played.  Therefore, auditions were open to performers from all areas. If a bassoonist, electric guitarist, singer, or kazoo player had more to offer than a violinist, that’s who would be selected. The group wound up involving 7 players:

  • Flute(s)
  • Saxophone(s)
  • Jazz trumpet
  • Bass trombone
  • Violin
  • Cello
  • Percussion

Musically, the good news about this unique instrumentation was the incredible color palette available. The bad news was that no music had ever been written for this combination. Also, because I didn’t know the ensemble make-up until the school year began, it was impossible to plan ahead and choose repertoire. But, as with any challenge, this dilemma provided an opportunity (described below).


The syllabus, and thus structure of the course, is one of the riskiest things I’ve done as a teacher.  After declaring that “The purpose of this class is to provide participants with valuable experiences and skills that will help them better succeed as professionals,” the various syllabus sections—mission, goals, objectives, literature, grading—were left blank.  In other words, students were responsible for determining what they would learn/experience (a proposition that was both frightening and empowering for them).  We began with several meetings to discuss desirable outcomes, and have regularly revisited this topic throughout the year.


The group was run like a true democracy, rather than the traditional conductor-driven model.  For each major decision, all members had a vote.  I was just one voice out of eight.  Partially because of this process, the players took incredible ownership in the ensemble.


In the past, the group had performed 2 concerts per semester, comparable to many other university ensembles.  While this tradition allows participants to learn and perform a good deal of (extremely difficult) music each year, it leaves little time to investigate other issues. 

The students decided to present just one unique concert per semester, though each program would be presented multiple times in different communities.  This decision permitted me something I’ve never experienced before in my teaching career: time!  Time to explore, focus on process, take some chances, try new things, memorize music, plan, reflect.  And learn!


Because approximately zero pieces for this instrumentation existed, we were forced to think creatively about which music to perform. 

We began with a focus on non-jazz improvisation (few of the players had prior improv experience).  Talk about the ultimate ear training development!  The musicians grew so much from this new experience, they decided to do a completely improvised concert.  Not only did their understanding of musical structure, texture, gesture, harmony, melody, and rhythm expand exponentially, but they developed a deeper understanding of their role within a chamber ensemble, and grew together as a group. 

Though none of the participants had prior arranging experience, they decided to orchestrate piano pieces for the group.  We then used several rehearsals as a laboratory: “try this up two octaves,” “let’s double with trombone,” “how about another articulation,” “listen to how a pedal tone/dovetailing propels the passage forward,” etc.  This kind of real time experimentation is undoubtedly the best forum for mastering instrumentation and orchestration (much better than MIDI!). Ultimately none of this music was performed publically, but the process taught great lessons.

We obtained music in the following ways:

  1. Call for scores. The group crafted and submitted a call-for-scores to several organizations, such as American Composer’s Forum.  We ultimately received over 100 submissions, and chose several to perform that featured a subset of our ensemble. 
  2. Commissioned orchestrations. We asked friends and colleagues to orchestrate existing works for the entire group. 
  3. Transcription/re-composition. As an ensemble, we transcribed and modified several pieces piece for our instrumentation.  While I coached them, students determined many of the ultimate artistic decisions.


Each ensemble member was assigned specific non-performance responsibilities, reflecting the reality of most professional chamber groups.  Sample duties included:

  • Strategizing
  • Scheduling 
  • Budgeting
  • Writing up the call for scores
  • Documenting tech notes
  • Contracting/directing tech crew
  • Building the set
  • Diagramming stage setup
  • Incorporating multi-media elements
  • Typing up the program
  • Working with PR
  • Marketing


We concluded the year with a debriefing session, reflecting on lessons learned.  Here are just a few of the many takeaways made by participants:

  • Being a chamber musician is hard but fulfilling work, requiring much more than great playing. 
  • We took more ownership in the group’s successes because we were directly responsible for them!
  • Not everything worked out right away.  Some things bombed.  And each failure taught valuable lessons. If nothing fails, you’re playing it too safe.
  • It is essential to work with the right people and create a healthy environment. We had a great experience, even when challenges were presented, because we respected and liked our partners both musically and personally.

The following quote by one group member illustrates the kinds of deep bonds that can develop when the right collaborators work together to create a collective artistic vision:

“If I had to be stranded on a deserted island with just one other person, it could be any of the members of this ensemble.”

  • Developing something innovative and remarkable requires vision, time, planning, persistence, and the willingness to take chances. 
  • Responsibilities need to be clearly defined, and early on, or valuable time is wasted. 
  • In a democratic environment, even one person can stall progress. So make sure the battles you fight are important ones.
  • You don’t need a standard ensemble to play great music. In fact, the challenge of programming for a unique instrumentation opens up a world of possibility.
  • Our catalog of lessons is much longer and deeper.  For a complete list, try forming your own group with this kind of model.  There is no substitute for experiential learning.

This article provides but a glimpse of what is possible through an entrepreneurial ensemble experience.  Such an approach is feasible with both chamber and large groups. Re-imagining the ensemble experience is just one more way music schools can embrace a culture of entrepreneurship at their core.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • Print
  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • Mixx
  • Blogplay
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz

88 Responses to “Re-imagining the University Ensemble Experience”

  1. Firefighters are the best the world over. Every life is worth saving. Bless all if you!!

  2. First of all I would like to say awesome blog! I had a quick question which I’d like to ask if you don’t mind. I was interested to know how you center yourself and clear your mind prior to writing. I’ve had difficulty clearing my mind in getting my thoughts out there. I truly do enjoy writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are wasted just trying to figure out how to begin. Any ideas or tips? Cheers!

  3. god says:

    Interesting area of written content. I just stumbled upon your website and in accession funds to assert that I get truly enjoyed accounts your blog site posts. Any way I will be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you obtain persistently swiftly.

  4. Great post, I conceive website owners should learn a lot from this weblog its rattling user pleasant. So much fantastic info on here :D .

  5. Qiang Zhu Hai city on the words heard in the ear entirely. In his eyes, what is the status Qiang, even not as good as toilet repairs! So he kept Well, are lacking, but not the angry Qiang, anyway, he has put into words, understanding Yiyi Hoi city that is willing to give his fix.

  6. Qiang Liu Yiyi would also like to add a big name, but she did not know much deliberation Qiang is doing now, think of his superb maintenance techniques, Qiang Liu Yiyi it casually closed a genius mechanic.

  7. Suggested says:

    Perfectly composed subject material, regards for selective information. “In the fight between you and the world, back the world.” by Frank Zappa.

  8. Continued says:

    Utterly indited written content, thankyou for information.

  9. I not to mention my friends were found to be reviewing the excellent techniques from your web site and so unexpectedly I had an awful suspicion I had not expressed respect to the web site owner for those secrets. All of the boys became as a result very interested to read all of them and have in fact been using those things. Appreciation for genuinely very kind as well as for going for such fine things millions of individuals are really needing to learn about. Our own sincere regret for not expressing appreciation to sooner.

  10. This means after eating, waking up or going for a walk.
    I had always heard potty training was a miserable thing
    that you just had to do to survive. It is best for smaller
    sized to medium pets as the amount of debris from a larger dog can easily be actually
    as well much to handle.

  11. Conditioning is a most important situation for the the greater part of the population nowadays. With much more and far more us residents coming underneath the world-wide-web of chemical compounds remaining made use of within just the day-to-day food items we usage, getting nutritious and keeping your immunity place is getting to be subsequent in direction of difficult.

  12. click here says:

    Just about every daily e mail of our absolutely free materials overview options e-newsletter goes out globally in the direction of persons looking for free publicity and substance evaluations for their solutions on the web. This kind of include materials promoters, entrepreneurs, general public relatives or publicity experts, and already hopefully your self, too!

  13. Every day-to-day electronic mail of our free substance study possibilities e-newsletter goes out around the globe to humans searching for cost-free exposure and merchandise assessments for their goods on the internet. People include solution promoters, marketers, public kinfolk or publicity professionals, and now ideally you, too!

  14. Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Extremely useful info particularly the last part :) I care for such information much. I was seeking this certain information for a long time. Thank you and good luck.

  15. I am only commenting to make you know what a awesome encounter my girl experienced reading through your webblog. She came to understand several things, which included what it is like to possess an amazing teaching style to let other people really easily learn about a number of tortuous issues. You undoubtedly did more than our desires. Thank you for rendering such valuable, trusted, informative not to mention easy tips on that topic to Tanya.

  16. review on FB says:

    Vacation spot a fowl, butterfly or charging soccer player within your binoculars, and snap a photo all with one gadget. The real truth, Regrettably, is significantly versus great. Electronic digicam binoculars were being an bold notion that in no way incredibly reached full potential; you will not likely watch innumerable models upon sale any more.

  17. It truly is much too a risk variable for nonlife threatening disorders, like arthritis, sleep apnea, gallstones and gout; and for affective disorders, together with lower self-esteem. With these types of a laundry checklist, professionals say it is in the public’s awareness for People towards eliminate that added bodyweight.

  18. Destination a bird, butterfly or charging soccer player in your binoculars, and snap a photograph all with 1 machine. The truth of the matter, however, is considerably versus desired. Electronic digital camera binoculars had been an bold notion that hardly ever definitely reached full potential; yourself will not watch several versions on sale any more.

  19. There really is a big difference between canine meals makers. Although the least complicated dog food stuff generally expense a lot more, they’re true meals and not filler — as a result your canine will not have to have towards consume as a result considerably of them, and the price tag big difference evens out, authorities say

  20. review on FB says:

    Destination a fowl, butterfly or charging soccer participant in just your binoculars, and snap a image all with a single gadget. The real truth, having said that, is considerably towards great. Digital camera binoculars have been an bold principle that never ever actually obtained finish potential; by yourself is not going to see numerous styles on sale anymore.

  21. review on FB says:

    Viruses induce extra critical destruction than spyware, however spyware is far additional typical. An accumulation of 1000’s of adware applets, which is not strange, is as crippling as a virus, and the worst layouts of spy ware can contribute towards personality theft.

  22. Reviewers additionally say the interface is straightforward in the direction of employ and is intuitive plenty of that even beginner buyers will be able in direction of go over their courses. Cost-free phone support is an additional furthermore

  23. Among Internet security suites, Norton World-wide-web Protection 2012 will become the perfect evaluations and ratings very inside of different lab checks. It accurately gets rid of all styles of malware, together with A hundred p.c of spy ware in just a consider. The consumer interface is greater and the have an impact on on process general performance incorporates been reduced, primarily as opposed in the direction of prior products, and all those advancements draw common praise.

  24. read this says:

    No person is ideal, but we can all agree some girls were being born with flawless, sparkling skin. If you might be not just one of them, a Excellent foundation can purchase you close towards best, natural-looking skin. The ideal basis for your self is dependent on your skin model and particular person decision.

  25. I am only commenting to let you know of the notable encounter my daughter undergone using yuor web blog. She picked up many things, including what it’s like to have an incredible coaching spirit to have other folks without hassle master specific extremely tough things. You truly surpassed her expectations. Many thanks for churning out the priceless, dependable, explanatory and as well as easy thoughts on the topic to Gloria.

  26. I simply wanted to jot down a small message to be able to thank you for the marvelous strategies you are giving out on this website. My extended internet lookup has now been rewarded with useful strategies to go over with my partners. I ‘d express that many of us website visitors are rather lucky to dwell in a good site with very many awesome people with good strategies. I feel somewhat happy to have come across your entire site and look forward to so many more enjoyable minutes reading here. Thanks a lot once more for all the details.

  27. Jett says:

    What’s up, yeah this article is in fact nice and I
    have learned lot of things from it concerning blogging.

  28. But access to Credit Score Information is very easy to do onn one’s own. All 77 million users worldwide are at risk
    oof identity theft due to this breach, and Sony should pihk up the tab for credit monitoring services
    for all the users for att least thee next two years. There are
    a few reasons why employers use a credit report as a tool for

  29. I got this webswite from myy buddy who shared with
    me regarding this website and at the moment this time I am visiting
    this web page and reading very informative posts at thijs place.

    Herre is my webkog – hair thinning On top

  30. Wonderful web site. Lots of useful information here. I

  31. There may be noticeably a bundle to learn about this. I assume you made certain nice factors in options also.

  32. Tangela says:

    Hello, its nice paragraph on the topic of media print, we all know media is a
    impressive source of information.

  33. Hello friends, how is all, and what you want to say concerning
    this post, in my view its really remarkable designed for me.

  34. Hi! Would you mind easily discuss your blog having our myspace team? There’s a great deal of individuals who I do believe would certainly revel in your content. Remember to ok, i’ll realize. Thanks a lot!

  35. It’s constantly so nice plus full of a lot of fun for me personally in person as well as the place of work fellow workers to find your site at the least three times in a few days to find out the brand new direction you’ve got.

  36. Ocie Balli says:

    Many thanks a good deal a lot with the excellent in addition to results-oriented guide. My partner and i won’t think carefully in order to promote your blog post to be able to any person who desires in addition to requires help relating to this spot.

Leave a Reply

Powered by Wordpress | Designed by I Design Blogs