Re-imagining the University Ensemble Experience

My article Re-imagining the Music Degree Recital explored ways that solo performances can serve as vehicles for developing critical career and problem solving skills.  But there are many other avenues with the potential to emphasize these aptitudes within music school curriculum. Consider, for example, the ensemble experience.

In Fall 2009, I began directing The Accidental Collective, Duquesne University’s premier contemporary music ensemble.  In addition to producing high quality concerts of compositions written in the last 10 years, I wanted the group to teach participants valuable skills about becoming a successful professional.  Please note: this is just one of many entrepreneurial methods for approaching an ensemble.  I do not recommend this format for every group or experience level. But it illustrates some of the potential available.


Success as a musician requires more than playing well. I wanted to stress that reality through even the audition process.  In addition to a traditional audition component, candidates were interviewed. This practice stressed that who you are is as important as how you play. Additionally, they filled out a form describing background, skills, and interests: secondary instruments, improvisation, composing/arranging, singing, public speaking, movement, additional competencies, reliability, willingness to take chances, etc. We also checked references.


Identifying the right members was also more important than the instruments they played.  Therefore, auditions were open to performers from all areas. If a bassoonist, electric guitarist, singer, or kazoo player had more to offer than a violinist, that’s who would be selected. The group wound up involving 7 players:

  • Flute(s)
  • Saxophone(s)
  • Jazz trumpet
  • Bass trombone
  • Violin
  • Cello
  • Percussion

Musically, the good news about this unique instrumentation was the incredible color palette available. The bad news was that no music had ever been written for this combination. Also, because I didn’t know the ensemble make-up until the school year began, it was impossible to plan ahead and choose repertoire. But, as with any challenge, this dilemma provided an opportunity (described below).


The syllabus, and thus structure of the course, is one of the riskiest things I’ve done as a teacher.  After declaring that “The purpose of this class is to provide participants with valuable experiences and skills that will help them better succeed as professionals,” the various syllabus sections—mission, goals, objectives, literature, grading—were left blank.  In other words, students were responsible for determining what they would learn/experience (a proposition that was both frightening and empowering for them).  We began with several meetings to discuss desirable outcomes, and have regularly revisited this topic throughout the year.


The group was run like a true democracy, rather than the traditional conductor-driven model.  For each major decision, all members had a vote.  I was just one voice out of eight.  Partially because of this process, the players took incredible ownership in the ensemble.


In the past, the group had performed 2 concerts per semester, comparable to many other university ensembles.  While this tradition allows participants to learn and perform a good deal of (extremely difficult) music each year, it leaves little time to investigate other issues. 

The students decided to present just one unique concert per semester, though each program would be presented multiple times in different communities.  This decision permitted me something I’ve never experienced before in my teaching career: time!  Time to explore, focus on process, take some chances, try new things, memorize music, plan, reflect.  And learn!


Because approximately zero pieces for this instrumentation existed, we were forced to think creatively about which music to perform. 

We began with a focus on non-jazz improvisation (few of the players had prior improv experience).  Talk about the ultimate ear training development!  The musicians grew so much from this new experience, they decided to do a completely improvised concert.  Not only did their understanding of musical structure, texture, gesture, harmony, melody, and rhythm expand exponentially, but they developed a deeper understanding of their role within a chamber ensemble, and grew together as a group. 

Though none of the participants had prior arranging experience, they decided to orchestrate piano pieces for the group.  We then used several rehearsals as a laboratory: “try this up two octaves,” “let’s double with trombone,” “how about another articulation,” “listen to how a pedal tone/dovetailing propels the passage forward,” etc.  This kind of real time experimentation is undoubtedly the best forum for mastering instrumentation and orchestration (much better than MIDI!). Ultimately none of this music was performed publically, but the process taught great lessons.

We obtained music in the following ways:

  1. Call for scores. The group crafted and submitted a call-for-scores to several organizations, such as American Composer’s Forum.  We ultimately received over 100 submissions, and chose several to perform that featured a subset of our ensemble. 
  2. Commissioned orchestrations. We asked friends and colleagues to orchestrate existing works for the entire group. 
  3. Transcription/re-composition. As an ensemble, we transcribed and modified several pieces piece for our instrumentation.  While I coached them, students determined many of the ultimate artistic decisions.


Each ensemble member was assigned specific non-performance responsibilities, reflecting the reality of most professional chamber groups.  Sample duties included:

  • Strategizing
  • Scheduling 
  • Budgeting
  • Writing up the call for scores
  • Documenting tech notes
  • Contracting/directing tech crew
  • Building the set
  • Diagramming stage setup
  • Incorporating multi-media elements
  • Typing up the program
  • Working with PR
  • Marketing


We concluded the year with a debriefing session, reflecting on lessons learned.  Here are just a few of the many takeaways made by participants:

  • Being a chamber musician is hard but fulfilling work, requiring much more than great playing. 
  • We took more ownership in the group’s successes because we were directly responsible for them!
  • Not everything worked out right away.  Some things bombed.  And each failure taught valuable lessons. If nothing fails, you’re playing it too safe.
  • It is essential to work with the right people and create a healthy environment. We had a great experience, even when challenges were presented, because we respected and liked our partners both musically and personally.

The following quote by one group member illustrates the kinds of deep bonds that can develop when the right collaborators work together to create a collective artistic vision:

“If I had to be stranded on a deserted island with just one other person, it could be any of the members of this ensemble.”

  • Developing something innovative and remarkable requires vision, time, planning, persistence, and the willingness to take chances. 
  • Responsibilities need to be clearly defined, and early on, or valuable time is wasted. 
  • In a democratic environment, even one person can stall progress. So make sure the battles you fight are important ones.
  • You don’t need a standard ensemble to play great music. In fact, the challenge of programming for a unique instrumentation opens up a world of possibility.
  • Our catalog of lessons is much longer and deeper.  For a complete list, try forming your own group with this kind of model.  There is no substitute for experiential learning.

This article provides but a glimpse of what is possible through an entrepreneurial ensemble experience.  Such an approach is feasible with both chamber and large groups. Re-imagining the ensemble experience is just one more way music schools can embrace a culture of entrepreneurship at their core.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Share and Enjoy:
  • email
  • Print
  • RSS
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Digg
  • Technorati
  • StumbleUpon
  • Mixx
  • Blogplay
  • Yahoo! Bookmarks
  • Yahoo! Buzz

142 Responses to “Re-imagining the University Ensemble Experience”

  1. Alexandria says:

    You don’t must have the capacity to attach to our internet site to explore our available
    visitors as well as provide a reading any place and even whenever you wish.

    Visit my web-site: –
    Alexandria -

  2. Isso mesmo curso mamãe sarada funciona e é preciso de apenas 14 minutos por dia, e foi pensado na sua rotina de mãe,
    então agora você não tem mais desculpas para dizer que não tem tempo, é único momento que você vai se dedicar a
    seu corpo e sua alto estima são 14 minutos por dia, e ainda em sua casa.

  3. Answering Service

  4. Advance Auto Parts has discounts (GO10 for $10 off a $30 purchase) if you want specific
    liquids in a timeis notice.

  5. Johnnie says:

    Só que trabalho desde verter essa Penosa Pintadinha para saxão
    e castelhano não foi a pura tradução.

  6. I love music, jazz, sounds alunannya very quiet and the players looked very dominate all musical instruments.

  7. domain says:

    Useful information. Fortunate me I discovered your web site by accident, and I am shocked why this accident did not came about in advance!
    I bookmarked it.

  8. Pegamos semi joias de uma tia a fim de qque vender, achávamos que iria ser supeeeeer simples vender, mas nos decepcionamos!

  9. Wonderful items from you, man. I’ve keep in mind your stuff prior to and you are simply too great.
    I actually like what you have acquired here, really like what you are saying and the way by which you assert it.
    You’re making it enjoyable and you still take care of to keep it wise.

    I can not wait to learn far more from you. This is really a great website.

  10. These footprints indicate that the species was most likely
    bipedal. Cars are expressions of us, closely tied to self-esteem and personal image.

    Achkan: A tunic with full sleeves and around
    neck which includes a length of 3-5cms on top of the joint is known as Achkan.

  11. Market, understood the vacation goers Freshly intend to travel, or maybe traverse take a trip
    corporations probably will be sorted out to realize the neighborhood travel element medical and health times by the
    preferred corporeal assessment sooner than starting,
    with them the whole emergency Remedies. They are always on their toes with a
    smile on their faces to serve you and make your
    stay at the Inn a memorable one and therefore there is no need to think twice about where
    to stay in Siem Reap, it is Angkor Discover Inn.
    Breakfast in hotel or local restaurant, you are transfer to Rabbit island by boat,
    for a short relax, then check out for coming to Kampot, to
    visit Teok Chou, and walking around Kampot to view the colonial building during
    French period.

  12. Hi friends, good article and fastidious urging commented aat this
    place, I am truly enjoying by these.

    Here is my wweb blog; growtopia hack

  13. Durante la emisión de esta programación ‘enlatada’, la pública pasará un letrero que permanecerá en pantalla un minuto cada media hora – al inicio y al final de los programas grabado de más de 30 minutos- en el que se informará al espectador de que la programación alternativa se debe a la huelga general, según el acuerdo de servicios mínimos alcanzado entre los sindicatos y la dirección de la corporación.

  14. But employing this function of hack features if you will eat one cellular, in that
    case your score will increase which means if you should
    be consuming one mobile, you will get two things incase you are
    eating two cells then you will score four things.

  15. Melina says:

    I do considеr all of the ideas you have offerᥱɗ
    in уour post. They are really convincing and cɑn definitely work.
    Still, tɦe posts arе too brief ffor novices. May you please prolong thedm a bit from nxt time?
    Ꭲhank you for the post.

    ᖴeel free to vieit my աeЬ skte Melina

  16. Helena says:

    De hecho, ahora, ciertos modelos dе declaración ɗе impuestos рara
    ciеrtos obligados tributarios ѕolo es posibl
    cоn lа presentación ѵía telemática mediante internet.

  17. I expected him to not move at When my dog wants to be outside he refuses to move, only moving to keep

  18. What i do not understood is in reality how you’re not really much more smartly-favored than you may be right
    now. You’re very intelligent. You realize therefore considerably relating to this subject,
    produced me in my opinion consider it from a lot of numerous angles.

    Its like women and men aren’t interested unless it’s something
    to accomplish with Lady gaga! Your individual stuffs
    excellent. At all times handle it up!

  19. You choose. We say desire to be the brand new in the event that you liked along with always
    played, then you’ll definitely love In goal would be to eat as numerous balls to rise your, in hitting
    another player means death.

  20. An intriguing discussion will be worth comment. There’s no doubt that that you need to write much more about this topic, it might not be considered a taboo subject but generally people are inadequate to dicuss on such topics. To the next. Cheers

  21. Kit Hartup says:

    Can you really have CPAlead widget in a Joomla site?

  22. How to allow other people know about your blogspot?

  23. A debt of gratitude is in order for this post, i have found this to an extraordinary degree helpful. i might want to learn more info concerning this.

  24. Moses Bolde says:

    I definitely wanted to type a quick note so as to thank you for some of the fantastic recommendations you are showing on this site. My long internet look up has at the end been recognized with wonderful concept to talk about with my family. I would mention that most of us readers actually are extremely fortunate to be in a great network with so many special people with beneficial strategies. I feel extremely happy to have seen your web page and look forward to plenty of more cool moments reading here. Thank you once again for a lot of things.

  25. Hey! I simply would like to give an enormous thumbs up for the nice data you may have here on this post. I can be coming back to your blog for extra soon.

  26. Hi I’m appreciating the time and energy you put into your blog and informative information you did. It’s cool to come across a post every once in a while that isn’t the same out of date remake information. Nice read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m including your RSS feeds to my Bing account.

  27. I would like to put together wordpress blog page that would enable people to join receive news letters and updates? Should i download wordpress to my computer? Will there be any pre-made templates for this type?.

  28. Marcel Manne says:

    I wish to show some thanks to this writer for bailing me out of such a matter. Just after scouting throughout the search engines and finding basics which were not pleasant, I believed my life was well over. Living devoid of the answers to the difficulties you have solved as a result of your good posting is a serious case, and those that would have in a wrong way affected my entire career if I hadn’t encountered your website. Your personal mastery and kindness in playing with almost everything was useful. I am not sure what I would have done if I hadn’t come upon such a thing like this. I’m able to now look forward to my future. Thanks for your time very much for the impressive and sensible help. I will not think twice to suggest your web page to anybody who requires direction about this matter.

  29. Will there be a degree that exists for use of music AND innovative writing two fields? When there is, do you know the name of it?.. I would like to combine these two of my interests (loves) but We don’t know what kind of level offers the use of both… Please help? Nearing college?.

  30. Peony Tattoo says:

    How long may my pc keep operating with an outdated web browser?. I browser my pc is outdated. However my computer’s little outdated as well, and doesn’t have what it would need to run the newest browser. Must i start saving up for a brand-new one, or can this issue be handled for a few more years however?.. By the way, I love my pc I may want to start over since I love all the programs upon my pc..

  31. My personal creator is hoping to persuade me to go in order to. world wide web through PHP. I’ve generally disliked the theory due to the charges. However he’s tryiong nothing the actual fewer. I’ve recently been using Movable-type with various web sites for about annually as well as feel troubled in relation to transferring to a different system. I have read great things about blogengine. online. Will there be a method I will transfer almost all my wordpress articles engrossed? Any kind of assist will be definitely appreciated!

  32. Illinois For Sale By Owner

  33. With every thing which appears to be developing inside this specific subject matter, your points of view are generally relatively stimulating. However, I appologize, but I can not subscribe to your entire theory, all be it radical none the less. It appears to everybody that your remarks are actually not totally justified and in fact you are generally your self not really fully confident of the argument. In any event I did enjoy looking at it.

  34. What i don’t realize is in fact how you’re no longer really a lot more smartly-preferred than you may be now. You are so intelligent. You know thus considerably in the case of this subject, produced me personally believe it from so many various angles. Its like women and men don’t seem to be fascinated until it is one thing to accomplish with Girl gaga! Your own stuffs excellent. Always care for it up!

  35. An obligation of appreciation is needed for this post, i have discovered this to an incredible degree pleasing. i might want to take in extra info regarding this.

  36. Can you type long blog posts within the PS3 internet browser?

  37. How can I get more individuals to visit my blogger site?

  38. How do I go about getting rid of articles that breach copyright?

  39. I am developing a joomla website for any boat membership and would like members to be able to upload photos of fish they caught. Additional info: I am basing the structure on the K2 component..

  40. Excellent website. Ⅼots of useful info hᥱre.

    I’m sendіng it tο ѕeveral pals ans also sharing inn delicious.
    Ꭺnd naturally, tҺanks fⲟr your effort!

Leave a Reply

Powered by Wordpress | Designed by I Design Blogs